February 06, 2006
The Hidden Blessing of Brokeback Mountain
Last week the Oscar nominations were announced and Brokeback Mountain, popularly known as the “gay cowboy movie,” has been nominated for more awards than any other film. Although not a financial blockbuster, the film has been heralded by critics as a cinematic triumph. Newsweek's Sean Smith wrote, "Brokeback feels like a landmark film. No American film before has portrayed love between two men as something this pure and sacred. As such, it has the potential to change the national conversation and to challenge people's ideas about the value and validity of same-sex relationships."
Despite Hollywood’s growing appreciation for evangelical viewers (and evangelical money), Brokeback Mountain was not marketed to church-goers. However, after reviewing Brokeback on ChristianityTodayMovies.com we received the following letter from Dennis Belkofer of Chicago. He is one Christian who saw Brokeback Mountain, and believes there may be a hidden blessing in this film for the church.
Thank you for your honest review of Brokeback Mountain. First, I want to point out that I am a born-again believer who has known the Lord for many years. I have also struggled with homosexuality most of my life. Because I accept the written word of God as truth, and because it teaches that homosexuality is sin, I have never accepted homosexuality as an acceptable orientation and lifestyle. For obvious reasons, I wasn’t sure if seeing Brokeback Mountain would be good for me. But, I saw the film anyway and I am glad that I did.
Watching Ennis shut down emotionally over the course of his relationship with Jack was like watching myself. But it didn’t depress me. Instead, I walked away from the movie with even a deeper love for Jesus because of how he has stuck with me during life and for the role that the body of Christ has played as my family.
As I walked out of the movie, a young man commented to me and two women standing nearby that he thought the film was going to be more about tolerance. Without thinking about it, I blurted, “No, it wasn’t about tolerance. It was about life.” Then I turned to the two women and said, “I have lived what we just saw on the screen. But, I have been saved by Jesus Christ and, even though he has more work to do, he has changed my life.” I’m not sure if they were Christians, but both replied, “Thank God!”
Yesterday, my pastor began a series on biblical prosperity—not the “let’s get rich and store up possessions” kind. But rather the prosperity that comes by surrendering to the Lord and allowing him to conform us to the image of Christ. That prosperity brings peace, joy, and contentment regardless of our state in life. Pastor made it clear that the prosperity that comes from God requires that we allow him to clean out areas in us that prevent his blessing.
Later that afternoon, several of my Christian friends and I met for lunch, and I shared with them my struggle with homosexuality and desire to be totally freed of it. I told them that I couldn’t do it alone and needed their love and support. They affirmed their love for me and promised to walk through the process with me. Seeing how Ennis ended up isolated and empty helped me to tell them of my struggle and ask for help. I don’t want to end up like Ennis. Neither does God!
Gay militants greatly over-exaggerate the number of people that are exclusively homosexual. However, there are far more people like Jack and Ennis than we imagine – many of whom are Christians like myself. I hope that Leadership and Christianity Today will turn around what Satan means for evil through Brokeback Mountain and use it as a backdrop to write about sexual addiction in the church. It could help others find the same forgiveness and healing that I am experiencing.
Posted by UrL on February 6, 2006 12:00 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blog.christianitytoday.com/mt-tb.cgi/49



Comments
Dennis,
Thanks for writing the letter. I hope you keep sharing your story. Much healing and deliverance is needed in the area of sexuality and other things as well. Why God doesn’t deliver us from desires He disapproves of is perplexing to me. My struggle much different but I want freedom. Being honest with others and asking for prayer is imperative but I really believe we need God’s power and release from strongholds. Especially our minds. Keep seeking, keep knocking and I believe God will give us victory!
Love you in Jesus,
Linda
Posted by: Linda at February 5, 2006 11:16 PM
Bless you on your walk. may you have the strength and peace that God provides, and walk in His love.
i believe that God can and does use anything. i disagree with encouraging people to see Brokeback because of that (see Relevant mag article by Andrew Seely) not because i am homophobic, but because my friends who have spent many years struggling and walking out of the lifestyle have told me that they wouldn't see it and they view it as propaganda for gay activism.
i pray that God would give us wisdom and understanding of the knowledge of Him so we can reach our world and see clearly.
Posted by: anita at February 6, 2006 12:34 AM
Thank you for your inspiring comments. It just shows that God can speak to us in many ways. I'm glad you have Christian friends who can stand with you in your struggles. This is a great example of what Christianity is all about.
Posted by: Daniel at February 6, 2006 08:35 AM
Thanks for your compassionate view. Unfortunately, the only way that God can bring some of us to have the love of Jesus for people struggling with different issues, is to bring us into direct contact with them. I did street ministry in Atlanta for a few years and developed a deeper compassion for both active homosexuals and drug addicts/alcoholics. I felt for the first time like I kind of understood what the Bible means when it says Jesus had compassion on the people because they were "harassed and without a shepherd."
Bless you, Dennis, as you fight the good fight. May God bring more people to you who will encourage you and fight with you and for you. May God change the hearts and minds of those who would see the struggle or the sin before seeing the person.
Posted by: Art at February 6, 2006 09:10 AM
I read your letter with great interest, because I joined the ex-gay movement more than 15 years ago. Many times I went to meetings and heard others speak of their loneliness and heartbreak, and their feeling of alienation from God because of their inability to accept their homosexuality. Week after week, I saw the same, sorrowful faces, praying fervently that God release them from their torment. I went to the group over the course of 18 months, and I saw so much pain and shame I don't think I will ever forget it. These were people whose families has rejected them, and whose religion made them feel as though their feelings of sexuality and intimacy were perverse, dysfunctional symptoms of some sort of mental illness. Personally, the pain that this movement caused in my life affected my self-esteem terribly, and the idea that God was somehow less than pleased with something so integral to my identity gave me such sadness. I was not defined by my sexuality - growing up in rural Alberta, I was lucky enough to have been given a very balanced view of myself - but the attraction I felt to men was integral to my development and my perspective.
In the time that has followed my departure from that group, I have realized that embracing myself and the love that I feel, is truly a holy, God-affirming experience, and the man that I now love has given me the humility and security I craved so that now I am closer to glorifying God, and others, in a way that I could never have been before - crippled, self-loathing, and ashamed before God. The shame was not for being gay - it was for letting others convince me it was a disappointment to God. I am stronger, healthier, and more full of love now than I have ever been, and I am very grateful that I was able to escape the terrible, poisonous world of the ex-gay movement. Good luck to you.
Posted by: Brad at February 6, 2006 11:26 AM
I also am a Christian since I was 17, and I'm 52 now. I am in a 19 year committed relationship with my Gay partner. We have an active family and are glad for this movie at this time when the church in the U.S. has become so vile and hateful. We know what it is to live Brokeback Mountain and know that God loves us and accepts us as for who we are. That's where our freedom comes from ... Not the letter of the law as written by men (some sharing their feelings, and others inspired by God and His ideals). The article as it was written still points to the way the church and its leaders want to control and possess what is God's. It's written from a view of self-hate and control.
Posted by: Raymond Hickman at February 6, 2006 02:04 PM
It seems as if you have had a very difficult life to date and I'm sorry to hear that. I don't mean this as a criticism but it's disheartening to notice that your letter shows very little excitement for a non-homosexual lifestyle. If seeing the film was such a catharthis one would expect your letter would be full of joy at the idea of becoming heterosexual. Instead you make oblique references to God's love and talk only of struggle in your future. I am sorry to hear that you believe spending the rest of your life in denial is what Christ is asking of you. I hope He finds a better solution for you.
Posted by: Peter Marshall at February 6, 2006 02:41 PM
I think one of the major problems with Christianity today is that we do not teach tolerance. If we want to spread the word of the Lord, maybe we should start emulating how he lived his life.
Posted by: John Schwartz at February 6, 2006 02:43 PM
I would like to offer Dennis a life with Jesus that embraces Dennis' love and sexual desires for other men. A life without struggling to understand what's right and what's wrong. A life of Christian ideals and morals. He simply needs to find peace and acceptance from Jesus’ words and from God's examples of loving Christian partnerships including those of the same sex.
I know many of you are going to be quick to judge me as blasphemous and doing the Devil's work. I've had to wrestle with "hate the sin, love the sinner" mentalities with many of my fellow Christian friends. It wasn't until I spoke and prayed with a minister at my local congregation that I understood God's true plan for me--and that was for me to find and accept a deep, loving partnership from another human being (be that woman or man), and to go forth as a demonstration of His tolerance.
Happiness without struggle is out there, Dennis. I know. It may not be in the gay bars and the "scene". Many of them are lost. It's hard to find, but with a lot of prayer and guidance, you can find it. In fact, I'm extremely happy and am blessed to have been in a very loving relationship with my partner Mark for the past ten years. And I thank Jesus every day for His grace in my acceptance of His plan. Controversial for some, yes. But remember when us Christians suffered persecution for following His way--I see this as no different for me.
Regarding Brokeback Mountain--I agree that Ennis suffered because he was in love with a man, and tragedy truly devastated one and all. But Jesus never said that life was to be without tragedy and pain. It's all in His plan. The sad part is where my fellow Christians are helping to propel the tragedy further by not accepting Jesus’ desire for all of us to find loving relationships--heterosexual or homosexual.
Dave
Posted by: Dave at February 6, 2006 04:36 PM