« Ur Video: Alan Hirsch on Mission & Incarnation | Main | I Read Dead People »
January 24, 2011
Eleven Trends for 2011
Strategist Will Mancini says small, social, and tech-savvy churches will be gaining momentum in the year ahead.
Will Mancini, church “clarity evangelist” and author of Church Unique, is committed to helping churches find their vision for ministry. His work gives him an interesting view of the ministry landscape. Below are his predictions about new and enduring trends we can expect in North American ministry in 2011 and beyond. This post originally appeared at Will’s blog. We’ve condensed it here with his permission.
1: Increasing diversity of opinion about what good vision and strategy look like
In 2010, Craig Groeschel posted on the Death of the 5 Year Plan, yet vision mavens like Jim Collins still talk about 20-year BHAGs (Big Hairy Audacious Goals). To add to the confusion, the list of “how-to-do-church” books grows exponentially. We’ve gone from simple, deep, organic and total to sticky, viral, dangerous and hybrid. Are we getting clear yet?
2: Articulating the biggest picture will be the leader’s greatest asset
Every church leader is saturated with countless best practices, bombarded with more communication, and ministering to people struggling with increasingly complex lives. This gives us a hyper-need for clarity. Communicating Jesus-centered meaning in life has never had more competition. The best leaders won’t take the most basic assumptions for granted.
3: Social media will open new possibilities for more churches
Unfortunately most churches lag behind the “real world” by 10 years or so when it comes to technology and communication. But online giants like LifeChurch.tv not only lead the way with technology, but do so generously by offering sites and apps like VideoTeaching.com and YouVersion.com. There is a new world of possibilities for vision and strategy not just for large churches but for every spiritual leader with an innovative spirit. Church online, Facebook, and Twitter are just the tip of the iceberg. For example, check out Gordon Marcy, John Saddington, Charles Lee, and Terry Storch.
4: Visioning and spiritual formation will emerge more visibly as disciplines
True visioning in the local church should always be a Spirit-led, Word-anchored exercise of daily spiritual formation. But it is easy to separate the strategic and the spiritual in daily practice. In the future there will be little tolerance for strategic conversations and visioning exercises that aren’t first God-worshipping and God-listening initiatives. Church leaders are tired of anything in the name of vision that smacks of corporate ideology.
5: Small will continue to be the new big
Thinking, acting, and leading small will continue to mark the church landscape. One factor is the new normal of multi-site churches. Leadership Network played a key role in accelerating this innovation which helps larger churches expand through smaller beachheads. Second, as church planting and missional thinking continue to expand, smaller expressions—from house churches to missional communities—become more legit against the traditional, monolithic measurement of big-church-butts-in-seats. We have recently witnessed the birth of a new network to small town, small church America called The Sticks. Last year brought counter-intuitive book titles and blog posts like The Strategically Small Church and The Micro Manifesto.
6: Networks will become the new denominations
As new learning, new strategies, and new relationships cluster in frontline church planting networks—Acts 29, Redeemer City to City, New Thing, ARC, ChurchPlanters.com, PLNTD, Vision360 and the ICF Movement—the knowledge, encouragement, and accountability of traditional denominations become less valuable. Please note that these networks are not trying to be new denominations. Some effective networks, like Stadia and the Church Multiplication Network, are denominationally based. But the momentum of these networks is changing the game.
7: Leaders will pay more attention to shorter time horizons
The emphasis on leadership in the future will be preparing for the uncertainties of the future, rather than trying to predict them. As a result, answering the question, “Where is God taking us?” requires a 90-day focus and a 1-year horizon of shared storytelling like never before. Will other time horizons be important? Yes they will, but not like the way we used to think about it.
8: The intersection of personal and organizational vision will be magnified
Peter Drucker recognized early on that the movement from an industrial to an information paradigm would push the envelope on personal clarity and self-management for business and non-profit leaders. Yet I find very little evidence in the ministry world that a hunger for personal clarity is making an organizational difference. Even so, I suspect this is coming.
9: Visioning will involve making meaning rather than predicting the future
Life brings a daily tidal wave of monotony. We all fight to keep our daily routine vital and life-giving in view of greater purposes. A key attribute of vision is and always will be how it keeps people focused on the future. But one aspect of vision that will bring increasing value is how it refocuses our work today. This is why I like the word “clarity” as a practical substitute for “vision,” especially in church. Expect that people will not care about where your church is going until you can make meaning for them right now. Why am I in worship? Why should I participate in a small group? Why should I give to your church? Clarity today before you envision tomorrow.
10: External focus and biblical justice will stay prominent
Now that biblical justice has returned to mainstream evangelicalism, it will remain a prominent feature in our vision and strategy work. Strengthening this trend will be a generation of Millennials who will rise in organizational leadership. They mark an era of altruism where volunteerism and social entrepreneurship are the standard not the exception. Generationally speaking, they care more about people “outside of the organization” than the boomers did. The mantra we will continue to see, sparked by Eric Swanson, is “Don’t be the best church in the community; be the best church for the community.
11: Churches will consult for vision clarity rather than for capital campaigns
For almost four decades, capital campaign consulting has been the dominant category for “strategic outsiders” in local churches. The role of consulting is moving away from packaged campaigns and programs towards the ability to navigate organic and culture-savvy solutions. Help in clarifying vision has become the most common reason for a pastor to pursue a consultant, according to the Society of Church Consulting.
Comments
I resonate with much of what is said, but I love the thoughts under point 9, substituting "vision" for "clarity." It's so true that the less we understand where we are and why we're here, the less we really care where we're going and how we'll get there.
Posted By: Drew Bekius | January 24, 2011 9:42 AM
I'll take the contrarian position and say that the inverse of all eleven of his points will occur.
Namely because I default to...
1)the unpredictability of man,
2)the inconsistency that exists with theoretical vs actual outcomes,
3)the Law of Unintended Consequences,
and
4)the old business adage that says past performance does not guarantee future results.
Statistically speaking, the odds are in my favor that I am right.
Posted By: sheerahkahn | January 24, 2011 11:45 AM
12. Jesus will continue to ignore trends and wait patiently for obedient disciples to join him in his kingdom work.
Posted By: Joel Zehring | January 24, 2011 2:50 PM
Let me try that again without the pith...
It strikes me that this list is a great description of some common characteristics of some churches in the very recent past.
It fails to address the supernatural reality that God delights in using the unlikely and the unexpected to do great works so that all the glory is directed to him.
It's been my experience that when churches ride the waves of the latest trends to growth, the organizers tend to take the glory for themselves.
I'm not convinced that Jesus is interested in expressing himself through organizations and ministry executives who set themselves up to receive the credit for the results.
Here's a more sincere number 12: Where obedient believers consistently gather to pray, God will move in unexplainable ways to expand his kingdom. These movements will leave in their wakes miraculously transformed lives.
Posted By: Joel Zehring | January 24, 2011 3:39 PM
On number 10.
It really is amazing what a focus this generation has on justice, volunteerism, etc... But at the same time, I feel like it's been publicized to be more than it really is.
Either way, the church has got to get in on this.
Posted By: Usedearplugs | January 24, 2011 4:06 PM
One thing that wont change is the use of lists to tell us what the next trend is going to be..
Posted By: chefjef | January 24, 2011 6:54 PM
Thanks for posting this list. For me, the value of such a list is not the accuracy of the author's predictions. Rather, I find reading such a list will often trigger thoughts about my own congregation and context. That alone makes such a list valuable.
Looking at the "ministry landscape" is important for those of us who are a part of congregational ministry. Far too often, we can get so focused on our own immediate context that we don't look down the road. Thanks.
Posted By: Jim Martin | January 25, 2011 4:44 AM
I'm not sure I think it's ever right to "be the best church", whether it's in the neighborhood or for the neighborhood. Growing up, I really cringed at the hokey amateurism of my church, and read jealously about how good the seeker-sensitive churches were doing everything. But excellence is an idol, too. Rather than being the "best" we ought to be faithful to our particular calling, whatever that is, in whatever context. Clarity in vision is indeed key, but not because we need to beat the other churches.
Posted By: Nate | January 25, 2011 3:22 PM
Is there a Rosetta Stone software for Church Consultant-Speak?
Posted By: Dave | January 27, 2011 8:08 AM
It seems that we need The Titus Mandate, right?
Posted By: grace and peace | January 27, 2011 8:24 AM
I'm sorry, but after going through the dense and at times opaque jargon a couple of times, I have to wonder what's wrong with this: "It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us ..." (Acts 15:28) It drove the church in Acts. Isn't that "sophisticated" enough for us?
Posted By: DPT | January 27, 2011 3:13 PM
I have to agree, DPT, I was thinking that this list was filled with jargon. Dense and opaque were good descriptors, but I would add repetitive. . . how often did vision/visioning come up in 11 points? I'm not saying this to be nasty, but rather it made me think that as I have grown older we have exchanged the "Christianese" of my church of the 80's for a "christian/businessese" of the new millenium. Anyone who doesn't read the right books or hang out with the right people would have NO idea what this article was getting at.
Posted By: Mark | January 27, 2011 11:03 PM
Post a comment: